Results and Next Steps
The project’s target group comprises approximately 250,000 companies in Switzerland with electricity consumption ranging from 10 to 500 MWh. The majority of these companies operate in the “Other Services” or “Retail” sectors. Typically, they employ fewer than 10 people and have annual energy costs of less than CHF 15,000. We can assume that most of these companies are purely office-based operations without their own production facilities.
In the service sector, the SFOE estimates an economic electricity savings potential of 30%. Collectively, our target group thus represents a savings potential of 6.5% of Switzerland’s total electricity consumption (final energy), or 3,800 GWh per year. Viewed as a whole, the target group is therefore highly attractive for energy efficiency measures.
However, when looking at individual companies, the cost-benefit ratio for providers of energy efficiency programs may be unfavorable. Consequently, it may sometimes seem as though providers of energy efficiency programs tend to avoid this “unprofitable” target group.
But how can this target group be reached on a large scale? How should energy-efficiency programs ideally be designed to take into account the specific situation of many SMEs? What is the best way to market them?
Finding 2: Existing energy efficiency programs usually lack performance monitoring
Most providers of energy-efficiency programs have so far refrained from conducting careful and scientifically sound evaluations of their programs’ effectiveness - possibly to avoid further worsening the cost-benefit ratio.
According to our findings, no comprehensive assumptions were made about the target group and its specific needs when designing the programs. There are no clear goals regarding the number of companies the program aims to reach. Nor is there a clear goal regarding the desired impact in terms of savings. Monitoring of the energy efficiency program is also generally lacking. Consequently, no adjustments can be made during the course of the program, and it is not possible to evaluate the program’s success. It can be assumed that individual programs were designed and implemented independently of insights from marketing and quality assurance.
Finding 3: The target audience is not concerned with the topic of energy
However, our target group, as described above, seems to be anything but easy to reach - it pays little attention to energy consumption. The vast majority of companies cannot provide any information about their own energy consumption or potential savings. While they all acknowledge that saving energy makes sense, they also believe that their own operations are too small to participate in energy-efficiency programs. This is entirely understandable when one considers that SMEs primarily expect cost savings from an energy-efficiency program, in part because virtually all energy-efficiency programs advertise significant cost savings.
If the typical SME in the target group can save, for example, CHF 1,500 in annual costs by participating in an energy-efficiency program, it is unlikely to perceive this as a “significant cost savings” given its other annual costs of, say, CHF 800,000. Furthermore, the annual energy costs of the target group - typically less than CHF 15,000 - show that energy-efficiency measures will not result in significant cost savings for most SMEs. It is therefore understandable for an SME to conclude that such a program is more suitable for larger companies.
Result 4: Highlighting Non-Energy-Related Benefits
Nevertheless, energy-efficiency measures can be attractive to the target group not only from a macroeconomic perspective but also for the affected company itself:
- Measures to increase energy efficiency are generally accompanied by the modernization of specific areas of the business.
- This modernization yields additional benefits that can significantly exceed the monetary value of the energy saved. A well-known example is the modernization of lighting, which creates a more pleasant work environment and thus leads to greater concentration, fewer errors, and higher-quality work (described in psychology as the Hawthorne effect).
- Quantifying these so-called non-energy-related benefits (NEBs) is sometimes difficult or even impossible. Nevertheless, framing the argument around NEBs, along with terms such as “modernization” and “innovation”, could be a promising approach when marketing energy efficiency programs to the target audience.
Result 5: Participation in multiple energy efficiency programs
The satisfaction of participants in energy efficiency programs with the results achieved is another key criterion. Virtually all participants would take part in a program again. Furthermore, those who have already participated in an energy efficiency program tend to see a higher potential for additional savings than companies that have not yet looked closely at the topic of energy efficiency.
Therefore, as a first step, companies in the target group could potentially be motivated to examine their own energy consumption through a low-barrier program. Afterward, the SMEs’ points of contact (energy managers) and energy consumption by fuel type should be known, which in turn could make it easier to encourage the company to participate in a more specific program. However, this would require - often in contrast to current practices - a more comprehensive approach to target group analysis, marketing, and sales.
A major challenge is the desire of many SMEs for comprehensive energy consulting. Such consulting would generally require the involvement of experienced and therefore expensive specialists. However, if such consulting must be conducted individually for each company, this jeopardizes the cost-effectiveness of the measures.
In this context, a sector-specific approach could prove useful. If a few representative companies in a given sector disclose the results of their energy analyses, other companies might accept these as a guideline. Furthermore, if the measures taken and their effects are carefully documented, this would likely significantly lower the barrier to participation in an energy efficiency program for other SMEs in the same sector.
- Subreport 1: Literature Review on Success Factors and Barriers to the Implementation of Energy Efficiency Projects for SMEs (PDF 1.16 MB)
- Subreport 2: Survey of Energy Efficiency Program Providers (PDF 633 kB)
- Subreport 3: Survey of SMEs on Participation in Energy Efficiency Programs (PDF 3.07 MB)
- Final Report for Project 1: Summary of Subreports 1 through 3 and Outlook for the Negawatt Project 2 (PDF 1.31 MB)
Increase concern
The target group’s low level of self-reported concern about energy efficiency, as mentioned earlier, is likely the biggest obstacle to realizing the overall significant savings potential. As part of this project, we have discussed various approaches and have already validated some of them through a survey of SMEs.
Pilot projects to promote energy efficiency in the next phase of the project
In the follow-up project, pilot studies will primarily be used to test how the target group can be engaged on the topic of energy efficiency, so that the SMEs in the target group become aware of the issue.
In a second step, pilot trials should also be used to verify the hypothesis that companies that have participated in a low-threshold program at least once can subsequently be motivated to participate in additional energy-efficiency programs.
Further information about the project
Alle Ergebnisse und Downloads
Hier finden Sie alle Ergebnisberichte und einige Publikationen zum Projekt.
Projektorganisation
«Negawatt statt Megawatt» ist ein interdisziplinäres ZHAW-Projekt, durchgeführt durch das Institut für Umwelt und Natürliche Ressourcen (IUNR), das Institut für Marketing Management (IMM), die Fachstelle Wirtschaftspolitik (FWP) und die Kompetenzgruppe Entscheidungsprozesse in Umwelt und Verkehr (FMVS).
Alle Ergebnisse und Downloads
Projektorganisation
Hier finden Sie alle Ergebnisberichte und einige Publikationen zum Projekt.
«Negawatt statt Megawatt» ist ein interdisziplinäres ZHAW-Projekt, durchgeführt durch das Institut für Umwelt und Natürliche Ressourcen (IUNR), das Institut für Marketing Management (IMM), die Fachstelle Wirtschaftspolitik (FWP) und die Kompetenzgruppe Entscheidungsprozesse in Umwelt und Verkehr (FMVS).