Delete search term

To content

Main navigation

School of Management and Law

Service navigation

DeFacto article: "Neutrality: when it works and when it does not"

With the Russia-Ukrainian full-scale war going on for the fourth year, discussions about its roots and options for peace never end. Dr. Alina Nychyk and Prof. Dr. Florian Keller from the ZHAW Center for Geopolitics and Competitiveness explore the Swiss and Ukrainian concepts of neutrality and examine to what extent they should be applied in the context of current and potential military escalation.

Using the examples of Switzerland and Ukraine, Nychyk and Keller argue in their article that neutrality is more than just a legal status under international law. It depends crucially on geopolitical circumstances, the balance of power, the interests of neighbouring states, and a country’s own strategic adaptability. While Switzerland has benefited from its flexible and, for other powers, useful neutrality since 1815, Ukraine—despite a constitutionally enshrined neutral status—was unable to prevent Russian attacks in either 2014 or 2022.

The comparison of historical contexts is particularly revealing: Switzerland was able to maintain and refine its neutrality in a setting of peace-oriented democracies and without imperial threats. Ukraine, by contrast, borders an authoritarian state with expansionist ambitions, one that violates international agreements whenever it sees an advantage in doing so. Without strong security guarantees, neutrality in such an environment is a fragile construct.

The ZHAW authors’ conclusion: neutrality can be a valuable tool—but only if it is respected by all relevant actors and backed by strategic safeguards. For Ukraine, this means that without credible security guarantees, neutrality alone will not pave the way to lasting peace.

Privacy Settings

Here we show you which services may run on our website. You decide for yourself which services we may use. You can find more information in our privacy notice.

Our website needs these cookies so that everything works properly. These cookies are created automatically when you are active on the site – for example, when you change privacy settings or fill in forms. You can block these cookies in your browser or set it to warn you about them, but some parts of the website will then no longer display correctly. These cookies do not store any of your personal data.

These services allow us to see how our website is used, but we do not know who you are. By activating these services, you help us make the website better for everyone.