HTA Hand Transplantation
At a glance
The health technology assessment of the compulsory accident
insurance scheme of hand transplantation in Switzerland
U. Brügger, R. Plessow, S. Hess, A. Caballero, K. Eichler, V. Meyer, U. von Wartburg (2014), Journal of Hand Surgery (European Volume), Vol 40, Issue 9, pp. 914 - 923
Recently the decision-making committee of the compulsory Swiss accident insurance scheme needed to make a basic decision as to whether to fund hand transplantation under that scheme or not. A Health Technology Assessment was commissioned to inform decision-making and gain experience with applicability of the method. The following were main findings from various domains. Compared with prosthesis fitting, the outcome of hand transplantation is satisfactory for function and sensibility. Complications due to immunosuppression are frequent, sometimes severe and potentially life-shortening. The direct medical costs over the entire life span calculated for a 35-year-old unilaterally amputated base case patient were CHF 528,600 (EUR 438,500) higher than for a prosthesis. There are challenging ethical, legal and organizational issues. The committee decided not to reimburse hand transplantation for ethical reasons. The Health Technology Assessment has been shown to be a useful tool for decision-making in the context of Swiss accident insurance.